Cookies

German Chocolate Cake Cookies

We’re not a fan of German Chocolate Cake at all but these cookies? Fire! We’re all about turning cakes into cookies and these were a hit at my in-laws on Thanksgiving! These are easy to make and (in my opinion) better than the cake version! We used the Cake Mix Cookie base recipe we loveContinue reading “German Chocolate Cake Cookies”

Carrot Cake Cookies

Ever crave something you’ve eaten before, but you know if you make it at home it just won’t hit the same? That’s how I felt about wanting a slice of carrot cake with cream cheese frosting. So instead of trying to bake a whole cake, I cured the craving kind of by turning it intoContinue reading “Carrot Cake Cookies”

Buddy the Elf’s Breakfast Cookies

No pasta here! Much like our Kitchen Trash Mix, this cookie idea came from trying to use up a few leftover ingredients in the pantry. With Christmas around the corner and Elf on my screen, I was inspired to make something full of fun flavors – something Buddy the Elf would definitely approve of. That’sContinue reading “Buddy the Elf’s Breakfast Cookies”

Butterscotch Cookies

Anyone else remember those classic hard butterscotch candies from childhood? I used to love them! Recently, I’ve been experimenting with pudding mixes in my baking, and when I found a bag of butterscotch morsels in the pantry, I thought – why not turn that nostalgic flavor into a cookie? This recipe starts with the sameContinue reading “Butterscotch Cookies”

Cookie Week 2025

Tomorrow, December 4th, 2025, is National Cookie Day, and we’re back for another round of festive baking fun! Last year, we kicked off our very first Cookie Week, and it quickly became one of our favorite holiday traditions. This year, we’re keeping the sweetness going with Part 2! Whether you’re after a simple, crumbly classicContinue reading “Cookie Week 2025”

PokéDoodles

Inspired by the hit show Pokémon, these cookies are soft, pillowy, and coated in a sweet cinnamon-sugar mix, each topped with a cute Pokémon design! The base recipe comes from Beth’s First Year Blog’s Cake Mix Cookies and our Snickerdoodles recipe but we added our own Pokémon twist to make them extra special. Please readContinue reading “PokéDoodles”

Wrapped TREAT$

Sweet Surprises, Wrapped with Love TREAT$ has always been about good food made with love—but now we’re adding something extra. Alongside our love for cooking, we’ve always had a soft spot for thoughtful gift-giving. That’s why we’re excited to introduce a brand-new category on the site: Wrapped TREAT$. Each Wrapped TREAT$ feature pairs a character-themedContinue reading “Wrapped TREAT$”

Rocky Road Cookies

Rocky Road cookies, coming right up! This flavor was requested by one of our TREAT$ Voucher recipients, and we couldn’t resist making it happen. Funny enough, we’ve never actually tried Rocky Road ice cream before – so a little research was in order! This cookie was a last-minute addition to their custom meal, but we’reContinue reading “Rocky Road Cookies”

2025 TREAT$ Vouchers Redeemed

Every time we drop a new TREAT$ box, we send out a survey to our recipients. Their feedback helps us improve and makes our TREAT$ more delicious. For the 2024 drop, we offered a little incentive: anyone who completed the survey would be entered into a raffle to win a TREAT$ Voucher. So, what exactlyContinue reading “2025 TREAT$ Vouchers Redeemed”

Pistachio Cookies

The first pistachio-flavored dessert I ever tried was a pistachio pound cake my stepmom made, and it’s still one of my all-time favorites. Over the years, she’s also baked a pistachio honey bun cake that’s equally delicious. While she’s known for her incredible cakes, my baking specialty is cookies. With St. Patrick’s Day around theContinue reading “Pistachio Cookies”